Full coverage
GOP senator bungles ‘dirtbag’ attack on Jack Smith over a basketball mix-up
By Extra Extra Editorial
Cross-spectrum analysis, synthesized with AI from 24 sources · Updated
During a Senate hearing on Jack Smith's prosecutions of Donald Trump, a Republican senator attempted to attack Smith's credibility by referencing what he claimed was a basketball game involving a Maryland team. The senator confused the Iowa Hawkeyes with the Atlanta Hawks, undermining his own line of questioning. Smith was testifying to defend the legitimacy and non-political nature of his criminal investigations.
Left-leaning outlets lead with the senator's factual error itself, treating the mix-up as evidence of careless or performative grandstanding designed to undermine Smith without legitimate basis. These sources emphasize the embarrassment of the moment as revealing the weakness of Republican arguments against Smith's investigations.
Center outlets frame the incident as a notable moment of spectacle within a broader hearing about Smith's prosecutorial decisions, with some sources highlighting both the gaffe and Smith's substantive defense of his work. These sources balance coverage of the rhetorical stumble with the underlying policy questions being debated.
Right-leaning outlets largely sidestep the sports mix-up entirely, instead focusing on Republican senators' substantive arguments that Smith's investigations were politically motivated rather than legally justified. These sources treat the hearing as an opportunity to examine the legitimacy of the prosecutions themselves.
Key Differences
- Left outlets lead with the senator's factual error as the story's primary focus, while right outlets treat it as peripheral to the substantive debate over prosecutorial motivation.
- Center sources acknowledge both the gaffe and the underlying hearing content, whereas left sources emphasize the embarrassment as delegitimizing Republican criticism.
- Right-leaning coverage frames the hearing as an examination of Smith's prosecutorial decisions, while left coverage frames it as a failed Republican attack that backfired.
How this story is being covered
Extra Extra has grouped 24 reports on this story from 21 news outlets across the political spectrum. By political lean, that breaks down as 16 left-leaning, 5 center, and 3 right-leaning sources.
Its coverage-diversity score of 78 out of 100 means the story is being reported across multiple parts of the spectrum, though the volume leans toward one side.
On reliability, 16 of the 21 rated outlets carry a high or mostly-factual reliability rating (A or B) and 5 outlets fall into our mixed or lower-reliability tier (C or D). Ratings are drawn from independent assessments and are meant to help you weigh each report, not to tell you which to trust.
Coverage of this story has developed over roughly 38 hours, so the perspectives below capture how the framing shifted as the story matured.
Below, the same story is laid out side by side as left, center, and right outlets reported it. Read across the columns and watch what changes: the headline emphasis, which facts lead, the adjectives, and what each side leaves out. The story itself rarely changes — the framing almost always does.
Outlets covering this story: The Baltimore Sun, Arizona Mirror, CBS News, Tennessee Lookout, Louisiana Illuminator, Florida Phoenix, Colorado Newsline, Georgia Recorder, Iowa Capital Dispatch, Nebraska Examiner, Washington Post, Talking Points Memo, MSNBC, Missouri Independent, The Daily Beast, Straight Arrow News, PBS NewsHour, The Bulwark, Just the News, One America News, The Blaze.
Left(16)
The Baltimore SunBSep 29, 10:18 PM
Hawks or Hawkeyes? Senate hearing mix-up puts Maryland game in spotlight. - Baltimore Sun
Hawks or Hawkeyes? Senate hearing mix-up puts Maryland game in spotlight. Baltimore Sun
Arizona MirrorBSep 29, 8:31 PM
GOP senator bungles ‘dirtbag’ attack on Jack Smith over a basketball mix-up
WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in
CBS NewsBSep 30, 2:17 PM
GOP senator confuses sports teams during Jack Smith testimony
Jack Smith's Senate testimony on Tuesday included a mix-up by Republican Sen. Eric Schmitt over an Iowa Hawkeyes game, which Schmitt believed was an Atlanta Hawks game. Ed O'Keefe has more.
Tennessee LookoutBSep 30, 10:03 AM
GOP senator bungles accusation against former special counsel Jack Smith in heated hearing
WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in
Louisiana IlluminatorBSep 29, 9:35 PM
GOP senator bungles accusation against former special counsel Jack Smith in heated hearing
Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in attempts to
Florida PhoenixBSep 29, 9:34 PM
GOP senator bungles accusation against former special counsel Jack Smith in heated hearing
WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in
Colorado NewslineBSep 29, 9:28 PM
GOP senator bungles accusation against former special counsel Jack Smith in heated hearing
WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in
Georgia RecorderBSep 29, 9:22 PM
GOP senator bungles accusation against former special counsel Jack Smith in heated hearing
WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in
Iowa Capital DispatchBSep 29, 9:22 PM
GOP senator bungles accusation against former special counsel Jack Smith in heated hearing
WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in
Nebraska ExaminerBSep 29, 8:38 PM
GOP senator bungles accusation against former special counsel Jack Smith in heated hearing
WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in
Washington PostASep 29, 6:46 PM
Jack Smith clashes with senators over Trump probes, says he will not be silenced
Jack Smith returned to Capitol Hill on Tuesday to defend his derailed efforts to prosecute President Donald Trump, telling lawmakers he would not “be silenced by continued threats of prosecution” from
Talking Points MemoBSep 29, 8:45 PM
New Evidence Shows Just How Badly One Republican Senator Beclowned Himself in the Jack Smith Hearing
TPM has found fairly definitive evidence proving Sen. Eric Schmitt (R-MO) misread text messages when he attempted to corner former...
MSNBCCSep 30, 12:47 PM
GOP’s Eric Schmitt keeps digging after falling into a ditch of his own making
There was a time when a senator in this situation would simply fess up and express some regret. The Missouri Republican chose a different path. The post GOP’s Eric Schmitt keeps digging after falling
Missouri IndependentBSep 29, 8:24 PM
Eric Schmitt bungles accusation against former special counsel Jack Smith in heated hearing
WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith on Tuesday defended before a U.S. Senate panel his past investigations of President Donald Trump’s possession of classified documents and alleged role in
Missouri IndependentBSep 29, 8:22 PM
Eric Schmitt’s Hawks-Hawkeyes blunder and the politician he’s become
On Monday, Missouri Sen. Eric Schmitt showed he still knows how old-fashioned politics works. He helped pass a college sports bill he spent months negotiating with Democrats Maria Cantwell and Chris C
The Daily BeastCSep 30, 9:58 AM
Fox News Star Brit Hume Delivers Brutal Verdict on MAGA Senator Eric Schmitt's Jack Smith Fiasco
Fox News chief political analyst Brit Hume has delivered a withering response to MAGA Sen. Eric Schmitt’s botched takedown of Jack Smith. Schmitt, 51, had accused the former special counsel of lying u
Center(5)
Straight Arrow NewsBSep 30, 11:22 AM
Senator mixes up Iowa Hawkeyes with Atlanta Hawks during Jack Smith hearing
Schmitt suggested Smith was in Atlanta in 2024 and said he may have been there in connection with Fulton Co. District Attorney Fani Willis.
PBS NewsHourASep 29, 10:50 PM
During Senate hearing, Jack Smith defends criminal investigations of Trump
The prosecutor who led criminal investigations of President Trump for the Department of Justice faced questions from Senate Republicans on Tuesday. Former special counsel Jack Smith handled two probes
The BulwarkBSep 29, 6:03 PM
GOP Senator’s Jack Smith Ambush Ends in Spectacular Humiliation
Sam Stein and Andrew Egger give their takes on Republican Sen.
The BulwarkBSep 30, 8:17 AM
Jack Smith and the Republican Smear Squad
If holding Trump accountable makes you an enemy of the GOP, the party has told you everything you need to know.
The BulwarkBSep 30, 1:19 PM
Eric Schmitts the Bed
Plus: Trump’s dangerous, reckless embrace of AI.
Right(3)
Just the NewsCSep 29, 12:00 AM
Senate Republicans make their case that Jack Smith's probe was purely political, not criminal
The hearing saw Smith appear to discuss his investigations targeting Trump. Those investigations were related to alleged mishandling of classified materials, as well as 2020 election challenges and th
One America NewsDSep 29, 11:19 PM
Fmr Special Counsel Jack Smith faces scrutiny from GOP lawmakers, defends his prosecutions of Trump
In a public appearance before the Senate Judiciary Committee, former Special Counsel Jack Smith faced intense scrutiny from Republican lawmakers while vigorously defending his criminal prosecutions of
The BlazeCSep 30, 10:00 AM
Inside Jack Smith’s Trump dragnet
Jack Smith, the Biden regime’s former special counsel, is back in the news with his testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Tuesday. The Oversight Project has uncovered new records that don
Get this analysis in your inbox
The Daily Spectrum: one email, three perspectives on the day's biggest stories.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime. No spam.
New to comparing coverage? Start with our guides to reading the news critically.
Back to Compare