Why a court overturned Alex Murdaugh's double murder conviction
South Carolina's highest court overturned Alex Murdaugh's murder convictions in the deaths of his wife and son, ordering a new trial. The decision centered on judicial errors during the original proceedings. Murdaugh, a disbarred South Carolina lawyer, had been convicted in March 2023 in a case that attracted significant national media attention.
Left-leaning outlets emphasize the court's decision to overturn the convictions as a significant legal development, presenting detailed timelines and explanations of the judicial errors that led to the reversal. Coverage focuses on the procedural aspects of why the conviction was deemed flawed.
Center and independent sources provide straightforward reporting on the court's ruling and its implications, offering factual accounts of the decision without substantial editorial framing. These outlets present the case developments in neutral, informational terms.
Right-leaning outlets frame the overturned conviction as potentially advantageous to Murdaugh's legal position, suggesting the reversal increases his likelihood of acquittal in a retrial. Some coverage characterizes the decision as an enforcement of legal standards.
Key Differences
- Left outlets (19 sources) dominate coverage with nearly twice the representation of center sources, while right-leaning outlets (6 sources) provide minimal coverage relative to the story's prominence
- Right-leaning sources emphasize implications for Murdaugh's defense prospects, while left and center outlets focus on explaining the judicial errors and procedural grounds for reversal
- Coverage volume disparity suggests differential editorial prioritization, with mainstream outlets treating this as a major legal story while conservative outlets give it comparatively less attention
Left(19)
CBS NewsBMay 13, 4:20 PM
Court overturns Alex Murdaugh's murder convictions, orders new trial
Alex Murdaugh was convicted of his killing his wife and his son at the family's home in 2021.
NPRAMay 13, 2:27 PM
Alex Murdaugh will get a new murder trial. Here's a timeline of his case
Alex Murdaugh — the disgraced former lawyer serving a life term for the murders of his wife and son — will get a new trial in South Carolina, the state Supreme Court said on Wednesday.
NBC NewsBMay 13, 3:53 PM
Court overturns Alex Murdaugh's murder conviction
Court overturns Alex Murdaugh's murder conviction
CBS NewsBMay 13, 10:54 PM
Why Alex Murdaugh's murder conviction was overturned
Three years after Alex Murdaugh was convicted of killing his wife and son, the South Carolina Supreme Court on Wednesday overturned the verdict and granted Murdaugh a new trial. CBS News Katrina Kaufm
Washington PostAMay 13, 5:13 PM
Court overturns Alex Murdaugh’s murder convictions in deaths of wife, son
The South Carolina Supreme Court ordered a new trial, saying the 2023 trial was improperly influenced by a county clerk’s comments to jurors.
New York TimesAMay 13, 6:19 PM
Alex Murdaugh Murder Convictions Overturned by South Carolina’s Top Court
The decision, in which judges cited jury interference by a court clerk, upends one of America’s highest-profile homicide cases.
New York TimesAMay 13, 7:25 PM
The ‘Murdaugh Murders’: What to Know About the Case in South Carolina
A court overturned the murder convictions against Alex Murdaugh, who had been found guilty in the killing of his wife and younger son. Here are the basics of the entire case.
Democracy DocketBMay 8, 5:23 PM
Virginia Supreme Court rejects Democrats’ redistricting plan, throws out election - Democracy Docket
Virginia Supreme Court rejects Democrats’ redistricting plan, throws out election Democracy Docket
The New RepublicBMay 11, 9:03 PM
Democrats Throw Hail Mary to Supreme Court as GOP Steal Seats
Democrats asked the Supreme Court Monday to block a state judiciary ruling that upended their redistricting effort. The Virginia Supreme Court ruled Friday that the proposed maps were essentially inva
The New RepublicBMay 8, 4:23 PM
Virginia Vows to Fight Court Ruling Striking Down Democrats’ Map
Virginia’s leadership is preparing to fight its state Supreme Court ruling Friday overturning Democrats’ redistricting referendum. In a statement, Democratic state Attorney General Jay Jones called ou
Democracy DocketBMay 11, 10:22 PM
Virginia Democrats ask Supreme Court to restore voter-approved redistricting plan - Democracy Docket
Virginia Democrats ask Supreme Court to restore voter-approved redistricting plan Democracy Docket
VoxBMay 12, 4:15 PM
Virginia Democrats’ irresponsible new plan to save their gerrymander
Why on Earth would Democrats want to give these guys more power over elections? | Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images If you’re a Democrat, ask yourself a simple question: When was the last time something
The NationBMay 11, 5:53 PM
On Redistricting, Will Virginia Democrats Surrender, or Get Creative?
Joan Walsh Democrats must stop conceding that the only answer for various racist voting laws is that Democrats just have to vote more and harder and better. The post On Redistricting, Will Virginia D
Democracy DocketBMay 12, 6:22 PM
Missouri Supreme Court hears challenges to GOP gerrymander - Democracy Docket
Missouri Supreme Court hears challenges to GOP gerrymander Democracy Docket
Democracy DocketBMay 12, 9:27 PM
In blow to direct democracy, Missouri Supreme Court upholds GOP gerrymander - Democracy Docket
In blow to direct democracy, Missouri Supreme Court upholds GOP gerrymander Democracy Docket
Democracy DocketBMay 8, 1:21 AM
Court Cases - Tennessee Congressional Redistricting Challenge (NAACP) - Democracy Docket
Court Cases - Tennessee Congressional Redistricting Challenge (NAACP) Democracy Docket
VoxBMay 13, 5:50 PM
The Supreme Court abortion pills case, explained
The Supreme Court building on May 4, 2026, in Washington, DC. | Andrew Harnik/Getty Images Abortion pills have been on a bit of a journey in the United States over the past few weeks. It starts in L
LA TimesAMay 7, 10:39 PM
Louisiana urges Supreme Court to block abortion pills sent by mail
The justices are likely to act soon on emergency appeals filed by two makers of mifepristone, used in abortions.
LA TimesAMay 9, 10:00 AM
California abortion pill suppliers ready with workaround in case of Supreme Court ban
The U.S. Supreme Court is weighing whether to restrict access to the country's most popular abortion method, but California's network of online providers and pharmaceutical suppliers already has an al
Center(9)
BBC NewsAMay 13, 3:36 PM
Court overturns Alex Murdaugh's murder convictions and orders new trial
The court has ordered a new trial over the June 2021 killings of Paul and Maggie Murdaugh.
PBS NewsHourAMay 13, 10:45 PM
Why a court overturned Alex Murdaugh's double murder conviction
A murder conviction that gripped the nation and touched on power and privilege in the South has been tossed out. Former South Carolina prosecutor Alex Murdaugh was found guilty of killing his wife and
The HillBMay 13, 3:03 PM
Alex Murdaugh’s murder convictions overturned, appeal for new trial granted
Alex Murdaugh was sentenced to two life sentences in the death of his son and wife in 2023.
Al JazeeraBMay 13, 5:38 PM
South Carolina court tosses murder conviction in Alex Murdaugh case
The state's high court ruled that Murdaugh was denied a fair trial due to comments from a court clerk suggesting guilt.
AxiosAMay 8, 3:46 PM
Virginia Supreme Court throws out redistricting referendum results
The Virginia Supreme Court overturned the results of the state's redistricting referendum, which voters narrowly approved last month. Why it matters: The 4-3 ruling upends one of the most closely watc
BloombergAMay 8, 8:29 PM
What the Virginia Court Ruling Means for Democrats - Bloomberg.com
What the Virginia Court Ruling Means for Democrats Bloomberg.com
The HillBMay 13, 1:59 PM
Supreme Court weighs Virginia map, rules on Alabama’s
Virginia Democrats are embracing unlikely arguments as they plead with the Supreme Court to revive their congressional map. Will the justices intervene? And what does the high court’s recent ruling on
The HillBMay 13, 12:00 PM
Supreme Court opinion season is coming: Here are the biggest cases
Supreme Court decision season is here. President Trump’s firings of officials long considered independent. His birthright citizenship restrictions. Transgender athlete bans. Guns. Campaign finance ru
AxiosAMay 11, 8:20 PM
Supreme Court extends freeze on abortion pill restrictions
The Supreme Court on Monday extended a freeze on new restrictions on mifepristone, allowing the widely used abortion pill to continue being prescribed by mail. Why it matters: The extension, which run
Right(5)
Daily WireCMay 13, 1:17 PM
Court Overturns Conviction In Shocking Twist To Murder Case That Gripped The Nation
Alex Murdaugh will get a new trial after the South Carolina Supreme Court overturned his murder convictions on Wednesday, saying that a court clerk “placed her fingers on the scales of justice.” Murd
TownhallDMay 13, 4:45 PM
What Happens Now That the South Carolina Supreme Court Overturned the Alex Murdaugh Murder Conviction?
TownhallDMay 13, 5:00 PM
The Democrats' Response to Losing at the Virginia Supreme Court Just Escalated
Daily WireCMay 12, 4:20 PM
Democrats Go Full Insane Mode After Virginia Court Enforces Rule of Law
Last Friday, the Supreme Court of Virginia issued its decision, striking down Virginia Democrats’ attempt to redraw the Commonwealth’s congressional map. Had the map been allowed to stand, Democrats w
TownhallDMay 12, 10:30 PM
The Missouri Supreme Court Just Solidified a Republican Redistricting Victory
Get this analysis in your inbox
The Daily Spectrum: one email, three perspectives on the day's biggest stories.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime. No spam.