Supreme Court rejects Colorado's conversion therapy ban
The Supreme Court ruled 8-1 against Colorado's ban on conversion therapy, determining that the state law restricts therapists' free speech rights rather than merely regulating conduct. The decision allows licensed counselors to continue offering talk-based therapy aimed at changing sexual orientation or gender identity in minors. The nearly unanimous ruling surprised observers given the ideological composition of the current Court.
Left-leaning outlets frame this as a setback for LGBTQ+ protections and highlight the Court's willingness to prioritize therapist speech rights over child welfare. Coverage emphasizes the harmful nature of conversion therapy and expresses concern about vulnerable minors being subjected to discredited practices. The timing on Trans Day of Visibility amplifies the narrative of institutional resistance to LGBTQ+ rights.
Center outlets present the ruling as a First Amendment question, focusing on the legal reasoning about speech versus conduct regulation. Coverage notes the lopsided 8-1 vote and reports on Justice Jackson's separate position, treating the decision as a straightforward constitutional analysis rather than a cultural victory or defeat.
Right-leaning sources celebrate the decision as a free speech victory and frame it as protecting therapists' professional autonomy. Coverage emphasizes the distinction between regulating harmful conduct and restricting therapeutic speech, positioning the ruling as a defense against government overreach rather than endorsement of conversion therapy itself.
Key Differences
- Left outlets emphasize harm to LGBTQ+ youth and view the ruling as a setback for protections, while right outlets stress therapist free speech and constitutional limits on state regulation.
- Center coverage focuses on the legal framework and the surprising 8-1 margin, treating it as a technical constitutional question rather than a cultural or political outcome.
- Left sources highlight the timing coinciding with Trans Day of Visibility as symbolically significant, while center and right outlets do not emphasize this connection.
Left(18)
SalonCMar 31, 9:31 PM
Supreme Court rejects Colorado ban on conversion therapy
In an 8-1 decision, the court found a ban on conversion therapy for LGBTQ+ minors violated the First Amendment
NPRAMar 31, 3:59 PM
Supreme Court opens door to controversial conversion therapy
The Supreme Court has ruled that Colorado's law banning conversion therapy "regulates speech based on viewpoint."
VoxBMar 31, 4:50 PM
Why an 8-1 Supreme Court just ruled in favor of anti-LGBTQ+ “conversion therapy”
Transgender rights supporters and opponents rally outside of the US Supreme Court | Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images There was never much doubt how this Supreme Court would decide Chiles v. Salazar, a law
The GuardianAMar 31, 2:35 PM
US supreme court rules against Colorado ban on ‘conversion therapy’
Court in 8-1 decision sides with Christian counselor who argues law banning the practice violates first amendment The US supreme court on Tuesday ruled against a law banning “conversion therapy” for L
NBC NewsBMar 31, 3:03 PM
Supreme Court rules against state conversion therapy ban
Supreme Court rules against state conversion therapy ban
New York TimesAMar 31, 9:58 PM
Supreme Court Rejects a Ban on ‘Conversion Therapy’ for Minors
Also, a judge halts construction on the White House ballroom. Here’s the latest at the end of Tuesday.
LA TimesAMar 31, 2:28 PM
Supreme Court says state bans on 'conversion therapy' violate counselors' free speech rights
California was the first state to prohibit conversion therapy, which seeks to change the sexual orientation of minors.
Mother JonesBMar 31, 5:14 PM
On Trans Day of Visibility, Supreme Court Sides With Conversion Therapy
In an 8-1 decision on Tuesday, the Supreme Court ruled against a Colorado law forbidding licensed therapists from trying to change a child’s sexual orientation or gender identity—a practice known as c
SlateBMar 31, 6:49 PM
How in the World Was the Supreme Court’s Awful Conversion Therapy Ruling 8–1?
The Supreme Court delivered a major blow to one of the triumphs of the LGBTQ+ rights movement on Tuesday.
Talking Points MemoBApr 1, 12:15 AM
The Supreme Court Has Never Heard a Case As Easy As This One
This article is part of TPM Cafe, TPM’s home for opinion and news analysis. It was originally published at Balls and Strikes. On...
The AtlanticAMar 30, 11:20 AM
The Supreme Court Has Heard This One Before
Fringe elements of American society have never accepted that birthright citizenship is the law of the land.
SlateBMar 31, 7:21 PM
The Supreme Court’s Big Voting Case Embraces an Approach It Rejected Just Three Years Ago
Only a few years ago, the court confronted the independent-state-legislature theory in Moore v. Harper.
Raw StoryCMar 31, 9:46 PM
Trump rages as Supreme Court mulls case: 'One of the great scams of our time!'
President Donald Trump raged at what he called "one of the great scams of our time" in a new Truth Social post on Tuesday. Trump took aim at birthright citizenship in his post, which comes as the Sup
Talking Points MemoBApr 1, 12:15 AM
In Biggest Case of the Term, Trump Will Ask the Supreme Court to Change What It Means to Be American
The Supreme Court will consider President Trump’s effort to rewrite who gets to be an American citizen Wednesday, an attempt...
Raw StoryCMar 31, 11:18 PM
'Where were the lawyers in the room?' Ex-prosecutor ridicules Trump's Supreme Court case
As the Supreme Court prepares to hear arguments about President Donald Trump's executive order to rewrite the 14th Amendment to the Constitution and abolish birthright citizenship, former federal pros
Law DorkBMar 31, 9:19 PM
Supreme Court holds that Colorado's conversion therapy ban "censors" talk therapists
Justice Gorsuch wrote for the 8-1 court that the law is presumptively unconstitutional as to talk therapy. Justice Jackson dissented, writing that the “fallout could be catastrophic.“
Talking Points MemoBMar 31, 3:57 PM
Kagan, Sotomayor Join Conservatives in Finding Conversion Therapy Ban Violates Therapists’ Speech Rights
The Supreme Court ruled against Colorado’s conversion therapy ban for minors Tuesday in an 8-1 decision, with Justices Sonia Sotomayor...
The New RepublicBMar 31, 2:25 PM
Two Liberal SCOTUS Justices Rule to Overturn Conversion Therapy Ban
The Supreme Court on Tuesday struck down Colorado’s ban against so-called “conversion therapy,” finding that it was discriminatory to the viewpoints of people who want to torment LGBTQ+ people. In an
Center(5)
AxiosAMar 31, 3:46 PM
Supreme Court rejects Colorado's conversion therapy ban
The Supreme Court sided Tuesday with a Christian talk therapist who contended a Colorado law banning the discredited practice of conversion therapy to change minors' sexual orientation or gender expre
Al JazeeraBMar 31, 9:45 PM
US Supreme Court rejects Colorado ban on LGBTQ child ‘conversion therapy’
In an eight-to-one decision, the high court ruled against a law banning the discredited practice on free speech grounds.
The HillBMar 31, 2:16 PM
Supreme Court rules for Christian counselor in ‘conversion therapy’ ban case
The Supreme Court sided with a Christian counselor on Tuesday in her free speech challenge to Colorado’s ban on counselors attempting to change a minor’s sexual orientation or gender identity. Justic
PBS NewsHourAMar 31, 10:35 PM
Supreme Court sides with therapist challenging Colorado ban on conversion therapy
A Colorado law that bans conversion therapy for LGBTQ+ youth hit a potentially far-reaching roadblock at the Supreme Court. In an 8-1 decision, the justices sided with a Christian counselor who argued
The HillBMar 31, 3:08 PM
Jackson breaks with liberal justices in backing ‘conversion therapy’ ban
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson broke with her two fellow liberal justices Tuesday as she dissented alone from the Supreme Court’s decision backing a challenge to Colorado’s “conversion therapy” ban. “T
Right(14)
RedStateDMar 31, 5:00 PM
SCOTUS Deals Major Blow to Colorado Conversion Therapy Ban
TwitchyDMar 31, 4:40 PM
SCOTUS Hands a Giant L to LGBTQ+: Colorado's Ban on So-Called 'Conversion Therapy' Is Unconstitutional
ReasonAMar 31, 4:05 PM
Conversion Therapy Bans, as Applied to Talk Therapy, Regulate Speech and Not Just Conduct
Justice Gorsuch's opinion for a nearly unanimous Court today in Chiles v. Salazar (only Justice Jackson dissented) struck down Colorado's… The post Conversion Therapy Bans, as Applied to Talk Therapy,
TownhallDMar 31, 3:15 PM
SCOTUS Rules 8-1 Against Colorado's Conversion Therapy Ban
BreitbartDMar 31, 7:31 PM
Supreme Court Rules 8-1 Against Colorado Law Banning So-Called ‘Conversion Therapy’
The Supreme Court has overwhelmingly ruled against a Colorado "conversion therapy" law that bans therapists from helping minors align their "gender identity" with their biological reality. The post S
PJ MediaDMar 31, 4:11 PM
Read This Before Celebrating SCOTUS’s 'Conversion Therapy' Ruling
Daily SignalCMar 31, 8:45 PM
What SCOTUS Ruled About Conversion Therapy in Chiles v. Salazar
Can the government prohibit what a therapist says to a client behind closed doors? March 31, in an 8-1 opinion, the U.S. Supreme Court answered... Read More The post What SCOTUS Ruled About Conversion
Hot AirCMar 31, 5:20 PM
Supreme Court: States May Not Ban 'Conversion Therapy' for Minors
Just the NewsCMar 31, 12:00 AM
Supreme Court strikes down Colorado law banning conversion therapy for LGBT minors
The 8-1 decision impacts more than 20 other states that have similar laws banning conversion therapy
ReasonAMar 31, 3:49 PM
No First Amendment Exception for Professional-Client Speech: States Can't Ban "Conversion Therapy" Speech for Minors
So the Supreme Court held today.
The Western JournalDMar 31, 3:16 PM
Breaking: Supreme Court Sides with Christian Counselor, Strikes Down Ban on 'Conversion Therapy'
The Supreme Court delivered a major First Amendment ruling on Tuesday. In a decisive 8-1 opinion, the justices sided with a Christian counselor who challenged a Colorado law that she […] The post Brea
Daily SignalCMar 31, 2:35 PM
Supreme Court Rules 8-1 in Massive Free Speech Case
The Supreme Court held in an 8-1 ruling on Tuesday that a Colorado ban on “conversion therapy” for counselors unlawfully regulates speech and is viewpoint... Read More The post Supreme Court Rules 8-1
The FederalistCMar 31, 5:13 PM
8-1 SCOTUS Nukes ‘Egregious’ Colorado Ban On Therapists Helping Gender-Confused Clients
'The Constitution does not protect the right of some to speak freely; it protects the right of all. It safeguards not only popular ideas; it secures, even and especially, the right to voice dissenting
The BlazeCMar 31, 4:50 PM
SCOTUS rules on law banning 'conversion therapy' — and 2 liberal justices break rank
In a nearly unanimous decision, the Supreme Court has issued a ruling on one state's ban on conversion therapy for minors, resulting in an important First Amendment win and setting a possible preceden
Get this analysis in your inbox
The Daily Spectrum: one email, three perspectives on the day's biggest stories.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime. No spam.