South Carolina Republicans defy Trump’s demands for redistricting
South Carolina Republican lawmakers blocked a redistricting effort that would have redrawn congressional districts, defying pressure from former President Trump to pursue the map changes. The failure came after five GOP senators opposed the measure, preventing it from advancing. This represents a rare instance of Republican resistance to Trump's redistricting agenda across multiple states.
Left-leaning outlets frame this as Republicans standing against partisan gerrymandering despite Trump's pressure, emphasizing the democratic principle of resisting map manipulation. They highlight this as a meaningful pushback against Trump's broader redistricting campaign and present it as a victory for voting rights advocates.
Center sources report the redistricting effort's failure as a factual development in Trump's broader push to redraw maps in Republican-controlled states. They contextualize it within Trump's larger redistricting strategy while noting mixed results across different states.
Right-leaning outlets express disappointment with the Republican defection, framing the blocked redistricting as a missed opportunity to address what they characterize as unfair district boundaries. Some suggest the map changes would have corrected Democratic advantages rather than created partisan gain.
Key Differences
- Left outlets emphasize democratic principles and voting rights concerns, while right outlets focus on correcting alleged Democratic advantages in existing maps
- Right-leaning sources express frustration with GOP defectors, whereas left sources celebrate Republican resistance to Trump's demands
- Center coverage maintains neutrality by reporting the procedural outcome without strong characterization of the redistricting's purpose or implications
Left(10)
PoliticoAMay 12, 8:40 PM
South Carolina Republicans tank redistricting, for now
Tuesday’s vote doesn’t mark a definitive end for efforts to redraw the state’s maps — but it does make it harder to accomplish this year.
The GuardianAMay 12, 9:46 PM
South Carolina Republicans defy Trump’s demands for redistricting
Republican leader acknowledges ‘likely consequences’ for resisting US president’s demands to redraw map Sign up for the Breaking News US newsletter email South Carolina state senators on Tuesday def
Talking Points MemoBMay 12, 9:13 PM
South Carolina
“We are the most gerrymandered Republican state in the country already,” said South Carolina Sen. Majority Leader Shane Massey (R),...
Democracy DocketBMay 12, 10:17 PM
South Carolina redistricting: Lawmakers reject gerrymander in blow to Trump - Democracy Docket
South Carolina redistricting: Lawmakers reject gerrymander in blow to Trump Democracy Docket
The GuardianAMay 13, 1:00 AM
Trump news at a glance: despite presidential pressure, some Republicans in South Carolina take stand against redistricting
Five Republicans joined all Democrats in the state senate to reject a redistricting proposal that Trump is pushing for – key US politics stories from Tuesday 12 May at a glance As Republicans scramble
Talking Points MemoBMay 12, 9:57 PM
Redistricting Effort Fails in South Carolina after Five GOP Defections
South Carolina Senate Republicans became the first to buck President Trump’s demand for a post-Callais redraw Tuesday, sinking the amendment...
Democracy DocketBMay 9, 7:00 AM
Redistricting - Democracy Docket
Redistricting Democracy Docket
Democracy DocketBMay 8, 6:33 PM
South Carolina moves to cancel June primary to allow for GOP gerrymander - Democracy Docket
South Carolina moves to cancel June primary to allow for GOP gerrymander Democracy Docket
Democracy DocketBMay 8, 5:23 PM
Virginia Supreme Court rejects Democrats’ redistricting plan, throws out election - Democracy Docket
Virginia Supreme Court rejects Democrats’ redistricting plan, throws out election Democracy Docket
Democracy DocketBMay 8, 1:21 AM
Court Cases - Tennessee Congressional Redistricting Challenge (NAACP) - Democracy Docket
Court Cases - Tennessee Congressional Redistricting Challenge (NAACP) Democracy Docket
Center(5)
PBS NewsHourAMay 12, 8:59 PM
Push for South Carolina to join congressional redistricting battle fails as Republicans reject map
The 29-17 vote failed, with just two votes short of the two-thirds needed.
The HillBMay 12, 9:59 PM
South Carolina Republicans decline to consider redistricting in blow to Trump
South Carolina’s Senate on Monday declined to extend its legislative calendar to consider drawing new GOP-favored congressional lines, dealing a blow to President Trump before the midterms this fall.
PBS NewsHourAMay 12, 9:32 PM
Trump's redistricting push falters in South Carolina Senate but notches a win in Missouri's top court
South Carolina senators defied his push Tuesday, while Missouri's top court upheld a new map backed by Trump that could benefit Republicans in the midterm elections.
AxiosAMay 6, 11:47 PM
Trump's redistricting revenge tour heads down South
President Trump's revenge tour didn't just draw blood in Indiana. It put Republican holdouts across the South on notice. Why it matters: Republicans are being squeezed to approve last-minute new maps
AxiosAMay 8, 3:46 PM
Virginia Supreme Court throws out redistricting referendum results
The Virginia Supreme Court overturned the results of the state's redistricting referendum, which voters narrowly approved last month. Why it matters: The 4-3 ruling upends one of the most closely watc
Right(9)
Fox NewsCMay 13, 12:25 AM
South Carolina Republicans defy Trump, tank redistricting, for now
Trump warned he was watching closely as South Carolina Republicans tried to redraw maps, but five GOP senators broke ranks to block the redistricting.
Daily SignalCMay 12, 9:15 PM
South Carolina Republicans Reject Redistricting
Despite being newly empowered by the Callais v. Louisiana Supreme Court ruling, South Carolina’s Republican-controlled Senate rejected moving ahead with a redistricting plan that would have likely uns
TownhallDMay 12, 5:45 AM
We May Have Some Trouble in South Carolina Over Redistricting
Just the NewsCMay 12, 12:00 AM
South Carolina senators block redistricting push
The defection of the small group of state lawmakers comes in the wake of the Indiana GOP primaries, where Trump-backed chal
TownhallDMay 12, 9:25 PM
Disappointment Doesn't Come Close to Describing What Just Happened in South Carolina
The BlazeCMay 12, 5:15 PM
South Carolina GOP poised to erase district of geriatric Democrat who got Biden elected
Former President Joe Biden was stumbling long before he took office. He fell behind in the first three Democratic primary elections of 2020, placing fourth, fifth, and second, respectively. James Clyb
TownhallDMay 12, 5:30 PM
Ro Khanna Wrecked Over This Ridiculous Claim About South Carolina's Congressional Maps
Daily CallerDMay 12, 11:16 PM
Republicans Have Chance To End Racist Redistricting For Good, And South Carolinians Are Watching
'Answer the call'
RedStateDMay 12, 10:50 PM
Missouri High Court Smacks Down Redistricting Challenge - and Referendum End Run
Get this analysis in your inbox
The Daily Spectrum: one email, three perspectives on the day's biggest stories.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime. No spam.